Will whenever schedules are supplied, they are given which have 1 day of the times one to does perhaps not match thereupon big date since it during the real records. One particular example happens in Harry Potter together with Prisoner out of Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney describes 16 Oct while the Tuesday, even if sixteen Oct 1993 is actually a friday.
There are even contradictions within the instructions of this type. Eg, into the Harry Potter and the Cup away from Flames, each other 1 Sep and you may dos Sep are given as the Mondays and you may, in the Harry Potter and the Prisoner regarding Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is determined towards the 20 April, however, careful parsing of one’s text message demonstrates this may has actually happened no later on than simply March.
Together with, in the Harry Potter therefore the Cup out-of Flame people say that Champions had been picked on Friday 29 Oct, however, 30 October are a monday inside 1994.
In chapter 7 off Quidditch Through the Many years, they do say that the first Quidditch Industry Mug was held from inside the 1473. If for example the championship is held all of the few years, that it problems into declaration within the Goblet of Fire your 1994 Globe Glass was the fresh new 422nd. If Quidditch Through the Decades is right, the fresh new 422nd Quidditch World Cup manage indeed fall in the entire year 3161, however, if Cup regarding Flames is great, the initial Community Cup was held for the 306.
Historical troubles [ ]
As the collection, with regards to the Macau female timeline derived from the new Chamber regarding Treasures source, is determined regarding nineties, the fresh series have a tendency to seems like it is invest the latest late 1990s to help you mid-2000s, around concurrent towards the publication of your own courses. From inside the Harry Potter and Half of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a male pronoun to mention towards “predecessor” of your Perfect Minister of the United kingdom. Depending on the more than schedule, this should take place in the summer months out of 1996, in the event that Prime Minister is John Big, whoever immediate ancestor are a lady (‘s the reason earliest meeting with Fudge, the ebook states the fresh new election, but Significant wasn’t first decided and simply got more than immediately following Thatcher retired.
You’ll be able to, but not unrealistic, one to Fudge might be talking about a more distant ancestor, once the Thatcher grabbed work environment in advance of Fudge supposedly turned into Minister to own Wonders. (Even if one can imagine a scenario where Fudge try delegated from the Minister to have Magic to meet up towards Primary Minister as he, Fudge, was in a smaller sized workplace.) As well, brand new personality and history of the prime Minister portrayed appears to far more closely fits regarding Tony Blair than just off John Major. A post about Day-after-day Post cards one to Rowling was romantic with the upcoming-Chancellor of one’s Exchequer Gordon Brown (often considered a competition so you’re able to Blair’s management of Work People, whom succeeded your and you may turned into Best Minister), hence she could have been wanting to let you know Blair’s worst front side. In the event your instructions were devote connect with book go out away from Philosopher’s Brick, after that it skills create occur in 2002 (after Blair turned Prime Minister).
Although not, it actually was later on stated that 22 November is a saturday, which it was a student in 1994
The same situation pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who was said as being 665 during the time of the newest earliest book, however, Nicolas Flamel is actually a bona fide historic shape and you will wouldn’t have reached you to definitely age up to 1996, around the big date the initial guide was typed. The latest rebuttal for this is the fact that the day the brand new “real” Nicolas Flamel came to be does not correspond with brand new Nicolas Flamel away from Harry Potter.
Yet another problem can be found away from Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure as Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is implied throughout the series you to Hagrid gotten one reputation inside a few years out of their expulsion out-of school inside 1942. In you to scene regarding Harry Potter while the Cup out of Fire, Molly Weasley reminisces about Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper seem to convergence that have Molly’s age at school, it appears unrealistic one she remembers an earlier gamekeeper. But not, you’ll be able that Hagrid failed to getting an excellent gamekeeper instantly after getting expelled, but instead already been as the Ogg’s assistant. This really is plausible due to the fact whenever Harry thinks he have a tendency to feel expelled having flying on broomstick as opposed to consent in his first 12 months, he magic in the event that he’d be allowed to stay on since Hagrid’s assistant.